Wednesday, March 5, 2014

The Missing Scene - Monster in the manuscript

I hate to cut scenes, and the more times I've been through a manuscript shaping, polishing, and tweaking, the more painful it is to remove pages I've come to love. But I do it all the time for the sake of the manuscript.

As horrific as those amputations are, creating scenes to fill holes, provide key details, and, occasionally, replace a cut scene is harder. There are several reasons for this:
  • The new scene has to fit perfectly in between existing scenes (or at least do so little damage a complete rewrite of the manuscript won't be necessary).
  • The new scene has to accomplish specific things, and the characters may be grumpy about cooperating.
  • The new scene forces me to recapture the original mojo, and getting the mood, voice, and tension right is impossible. (All this, when I have been living in the judgmental editor space for days, weeks, or months.)
  • Once written, the new scene reads like a first draft -- because it is.
  • The new scene may be completely wrong -- and need to be cut.
So, almost everything is stacked against a writer trying to write a missing scene and fit it into place. Failure seems inevitable. Fear is palpable. Other than facing a blank sheet of paper, writing the missing scene may be the most courageous thing a writer does. To me, it is the monster, waiting in my pages to turn my manuscript into a 300-page corpse.

Nothing turns this into a wonderful experience, but here are some hard-earned tips.
  • Summarize the scene before and the scene after, so the context is clear without repeated rereadings.
  • Make a specific list of what the scene must do to succeed. (Reveal information. Create an emotion. Set up a problem. Engage a character. Etc.)
  • Commit to writing 3-5 versions of the missing scene. That way, there's no pressure to make it all work in one try.
  • Write a version your character wants written so he/she will leave you alone.
  • Put the missing scene, in its their versions, aside for a week before attempting revisions.
  • Align the scene with the lead-in, follow-up summaries, not the actual manuscript scenes, which are polished and may be intimidating.
  • Revise until you are happy. Choose the version that seems to be best, write down any likely rework elsewhere in the manuscript.
  • Read the chosen, revised scene in contest with actual lead-in, follow-up scenes (or the whole manuscript. If it works, polish and congratulate yourself. If it doesn't, try out a different revised new scene.
Can you take shortcuts? Maybe. Sometimes your muse is generous. But, if you need to grind it out, these tips will probably help you get the job done.

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

What's Wrong with Your Story? You Already Know.

As I was panning for ideas on writing, I came up with this gem. You already know. This came from a freelance editor (whose name I can't recall). The most common response she gets from professionals when she offers her biggest points of criticism is, "Yeah. I guess I knew that."

And you probably know what's wrong with your story, too. I'm not talking about typos or dialogue that needs sharpening. Good stories that aren't quite ready have other problems. Missed logic. The wrong starting place. Weak endings. Awkward back story. Secondary characters who take over or flit in and out. Dodged emotions.

All of these are fixable, but not without pain. It's tough to take a finished manuscript, completely rewrite a fifty-page section, and repair whatever that breaks in the rest of the work. A subplot-ectomy can be almost impossible without causing nerve damage. Killing off a favorite character or deleting the first three chapters? Agonizing.

Here's what I did: I took ten complete longer works and forced myself to quickly write what I feared most about each of them. I noted the unthinkable, without allowing any arguments. It was a little like going to confession, and that gave me the idea of listing problems to reflect on.

Big Ugly Story Problems
  • The story starts in the wrong place - It needs to begin as late as possible.
  • Beats are missing - These can be generic story beats or those for a specific genre, like romance.
  • Undigested back story - Those things the reader may need to know, but stated too baldly. (Or maybe they really don't need to know them at all.)
  • Tension that slacks - This can be because of a weak back story, plateauing stakes, or fun scenes that just don't belong in the book.
  • Experiments gone awry - For me, this comes from playing with structure or fancy prose.
  • World-building mistakes - Problems with logic, or rules made up during drafting that don't quite add up.
  • Tone and mood shifts - Inconsistency, often caused by inserting humor, passion, and sudden changes in pacing.
  • The ending doesn't satisfy - Too fast, too slow, illogical, not set up properly, too obvious.
  • Muted emotion - Not going as far with emotional responses as the circumstances and character dictate (often to protect the writer).
  • Pulled punches - Avoiding extremes and not going as far as the premise or set up suggests (often to protect the protagonist).
Yes. I found all of these among my works. Some stories have more than one. It's a very difficult thing to recognize, and it's even harder to accept. My suggestion is that you 1) examine your own stories for these problems, 2) force rank from worst to least all of these so you are certain you have really thought about each one, and 3) accept the first or first few problems as real and get to work on them.

This might be a way to get to "Yeah. I guess I knew that" without outside help so you can bring your writing to the next level. As a special bonus, if you have a half-written manuscript you still love, this approach might give you a clue as to where to fix it.

Oh, by the way. Please feel free to add to my list. And if you come up with good ones, I'd be delighted if you'd share them here.

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Delay Tactics

Do you keep your story going by making characters wait? In Cheryl St. John's Writing with Emotion, Tension, and Conflict, I found a list of delays (Conflict is not delay), and I quote:
  • The protagonist can't find someone or something.
  • She falls in a mud puddle.
  • She loses her keys.
  • She misses a bus.
  • She arrives late at an important event.
Since I'm in the middle of judging manuscript for novel competitions, these resonated with me. It's possible to get away with some delay within the book, especially if the writer plants hints ahead of time. ("Don't forget to put your keys in the key tray. If you lose them tomorrow, there will be horrible consequences.") Unfortunately, I'm seeing delay -- in place of conflict -- within the first pages of manuscripts.

I'm sure this comes out naturally in the drafting process, and I don't have any objections to writers filling pages with these weak moments in a draft. But, by the time the manuscript is sent out to contests, agents, and editors, these should be (mostly) eradicated. They create plateaus in the story where nothing much happens. They do not raise the stakes or (usually) test the protagonists in a fundamental way.

And I've come to suspect these emerge not so much from a lack of imagination as from fear. In my own work, I tend to delay things for the  protagonist when I am avoiding an uncomfortable or emotionally challenging situation. I think there is a natural urge to protect the protagonist. In a way we are protecting ourselves.

So, as you rewrite, when you find a delay substituting for a real conflict, consider getting rid of it. But, more importantly, look to see if somewhere, at the periphery of your consciousness, there is something difficult, nasty, embarrassing, or too real for you. Because, if you identify that, you'll do more than remove a dull section, you'll find your way to the awful stuff that really good.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Great Questions, Crazy Answers - Brainstorming by proxy

One thing that sets writing apart is originality. This can stem from surprising combinations, a fresh premise, a new perspective, or a distinct manner of expression. Some people are born eccentric and never get mashed into society's boxes. Others escape categorization or are (often painfully) pushed out by life events.

The rest of us must rely on our curiosity. I wrote an article some years ago on curiosity for innovators (which I'm happy to share on request). It ends with a list of ways to develop curiosity:
  • Put yourself into new situations that challenge your worldview (and imagine they are true)
  • Actively observe, rigorously recording the input to all your senses
  • Come up with your own list of great questions
  • Question the status quo
  • Give yourself permission to look at things differently
  • Build your skills at investigating
  • Have a perspective
  • Make time for curiosity
  • Be persistent
  • Keep notes on your observations, insights and conclusions
  • Solve puzzles
  • Get other perspectives
As I look through that list, it occurs to me that there is often an interplay between the approaches and curiosity. In particular, asking great questions can develop your curiosity, but, as your curiosity is developed, you are more likely to ask better questions.

The best question of all is "why?" The second best is probably "why not?" One way to come up with great questions is to reject conventional explanations (which is safe in fiction, less so in real life). We often accept a word as an explanation. (Why do things fall? Gravity.) That's never a sufficient answer. Probing more deeply can help.

I always recommend brainstorming, often writing twenty answers to a question, as a way to get to something that is surprising or even unique. One thing I've found is this does not work for everyone. They have a very difficult time generating a lot of answers, and they often twist themselves into pretzels to get "reasonable" answers. They are not comfortable with crazy.

And sometimes even highly creative people just run out of energy or feel stale.

For either of these, a return to the original approach to brainstorming is in order. Bring together a group of people and have them throw out answers (with no judgment). Reminding them of the basic rules of brainstorming can be useful, giving them permission to provide wrong and crazy answers.

What if people aren't available? One technique I've used myself is to imagine people I know well (either in reality or through their work) answering the questions -- what I call brainstorming by proxy. At times, I've taken this so far, in the case of fiction writing, that I have composed beginnings and endings for stories in the voices of writers I've read until I can write in their voices. That's going a bit far, but just imagining the answers from others may open you up to a kind of craziness that can be engaging and inspiring.

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

The Secrets of Fiction 2 – Isn’t it ironic?


Last time I wrote about story secrets. Generally these are the secrets left to the readers to unravel. Most mysteries are of this sort, with Columbo as a major exception.
For those who have missed Peter Falk’s finest moments (other than The Princess Bride), Columbo episodes always began with the criminal committing the murder in front of the audience. Each murder was carefully designed to make the murderer (usually someone who was clever, respected, and upper class – a one percent villain) seems unassailable. The audience was not in suspense as to who-done-it, only as to how Columbo would trip them up. These were ironic mysteries in that most of the people in the story did not know who the guilty party was. Only the murderer and Columbo knew that.
Careful viewers, however, might have another level of irony. They might see the mistake that the murderer made, something he or she was unaware of. The error was the secret hidden from the murderer, but obvious to a portion of the audience.
Irony is at work in other genres. As mentioned in the last post, Hitchcock was fond of creating suspense by showing a danger that the protagonist was unaware of. In horror films, the audience often sees the monster prowling or in wait for a hapless victim. (Don’t open that door!) 
In romantic comedies, we know one of the lovers has a secret while the other lover is in the dark. In some ways, irony is a close cousin of gossip. We get exclusive knowledge reflects our superiority. In fact, comedy usually requires that the audience be in a superior position, effectively looking down at the poor, clueless hero.
Perhaps the most joyful use of irony is the audience’s understanding that the hero has an unappreciated or unrecognized strength. One reason why this resonates is because for many of us, it took someone outside our families to point out that we had an important dimension, whether it was a teaching encouraging us to take up a profession or a lover appreciating our sex appeal. This can be life-changing, and it’s fun to relive it in fiction.
Whether someone gets caught, finds love, or changes direction, there are a few essentials for ironic secrets:
·      The audience cannot be informed in a way that is overly subtle. It is okay for people to feel smart because they caught on to the secret. But the more people who miss being brought in on the secret entirely, the less successful the work is.
·      There must be a reason for the secret. Ignorance. Social pressure. Confusion. In Some Like It Hot, the musicians keep their secrets to avoid being murdered.
·      There must be frustrated opportunities for the secret to be revealed.
·      The consequences of the secret staying secret must rise as the story progresses. It should become unbearable and lead to thoughts of, “Oh why didn’t I just tell the truth to begin with.”
·      The revelation or unmasking must be dramatic and risky. If it’s not a big moment, why bother. If things eke out bit by bit, the impact will be lost. We want burst balloons, not slow leaks.
·      There must be a sense of relief in the revelation. At last the truth can be told and the truth will set you free.
·      The revelation must create a power shift. In some older romantic comedies, there was a dramatic loss of power by the heroine. Nowadays, power tends to shift in either direction. But is also possible to make it a win-win.
It is possible to have stories that include both story secrets and ironic secrets. Mission Impossible did this in every episode (quite well in most cases). But the writer must consciously choose one or the other or both and execute either or both according to the specific needs without muddying the audience experience. The goal isn't to confuse. It's to thrill and delight.

Thursday, January 30, 2014

The Secrets of Fiction 1 – Spoiler alert!


Who doesn’t love a good secret? When a friend shares one, it’s an intimate expression of trust. Secrets can provide advantages that lead to power and wealth (think insider trading). When science unlocks nature’s secrets it can reshape our view of reality and upset the social order (think Copernicus). And, of course, a secret revealed can shatter relationships (not so fun) or lead to healing.
It’s no wonder fiction writers love secrets. They turn plot points, build anticipation, and twist endings.  O. Henry’s finales amuse. James Joyce’s epiphanies enlighten. The secret baby trope in romances throws relationships into chaos, and the reveal at the end of a mystery puts a murderer in jail and explains all.
For writers, secrets can be spice or the main meal. They are both powerful and dangerous because, as with sensitive information disclosed by a friend, trust is everything. Handling secrets, hints, clues, telltales, explanations, and revelations well can make the difference between readers who are enthralled and readers who are disappointed.
The first thing to know about secrets is two varieties exist in fiction. There are secrets kept from the readers (story secrets) and secrets kept from the characters (ironic secrets). Generally, the reader doesn’t know who-done-it in murder mystery until the final scene when the detective adds the last piece of the puzzle (though we love to guess along the way). By contrast, in a romantic comedy, the reader generally knows the secret of one of the lovers early on, and the other lover (along with other key characters) is left in the dark. Hitchcock loved irony. Almost all his films had danger looming in the background, creating suspense. He called this his bomb theory. 
I’ll discuss irony next time. This post will focus on story secrets.
The reason we have spoiler alerts is because much of the fun of story secrets comes from the surprise. We are sense-making beings, and nature rewards our efforts with a thrill (probably endorphin-based) when we put the puzzle together.
Clues Readers can only solve the puzzle, or properly appreciate its solution, if the storyteller provides clues. Now, obviously, the job isn’t done if a list of clues is provided at the beginning of the story. Clues must be sprinkled throughout the story in a way that seems natural and supports the pacing of the story.  Before any revelation, all the clues for that disclosure must be available to the reader. And the visibility of the clue must be appropriate to the story and the genre. In a challenging mystery, clues usually need to be carefully hidden. In a comedy, they may be obvious to everyone but the fool at the center of the action.
Sometimes the clues come from the behavior of characters. This can be a subtle thing, but the key to doing it successfully is to make the behavior consistent with the character’s knowledge, motivation, stakes, and personality. This may mean the character acts “out of character,” appropriately raising red flags. Often characters will seem to overreact when someone comes too close to a secret. But, by the end of the story, the actions and reactions of the characters must be justified by the facts, as known, at any given time. (Getting this right often requires subtle rewriting. It is rare that a first draft achieves the right balance.)
Revelations A revelation can be any piece of accepted information. It can be a fact that creates a turning point, redirecting action. It can be a key element of a resolution. It can be the resolution itself. Revelations expose character, shift power, point to solutions, explain, and can flip an ending (think of poor Oedipus).
An effective revelation is exquisitely sensitive to the timing. Too soon, and the impact is muted. Too late and the reader feels cheated (or has already ceased to care). Most writers make the first mistake (especially in early drafts). They are eager to share the information ahead of time, often as soon as they discover it. Withholding is good. Moving the revelation as late as possible in the story usually creates more tension. One more thing is essential: the revelation must be clear. This should be obvious, but sometimes, having lived with the story, the writer doesn’t know more explanation is needed. And sometimes the writer is too busy being clever and mysterious.
Resolution There is no more effective way to anger readers than in messing up the disclosure of a secret at the end of a story. The secret must be fair. It must make sense within the story world and fit the clues. It must be material. If it doesn’t matter much, you’ve created a shaggy dog story. It must be surprising. If readers have figured it out and are sure of what’s coming, it will be a disappointment.
For extra points, make the resolution evoke strong emotions. And, if you aspire to greatness, go the James Joyce route and make it meaningful.
Upcoming courses
Endings That Buzz - Answering the story question with clarity, emotion, and power (Feb. 3-16) Online
Endings are your last chance to make a good impression. A great ending can close the sale with an editor, satisfy a reader, and get people talking. Learn the four essentials of a strong ending. Find out how to reach "The End" and what to do if you paint yourself into a corner. Test your finale and discover how to finish your story in a way that will resonate with readers.
How to Write Fast  (Mar. 3-28)  Online
Crank up the efficiency and get that novel, short story, article or script DONE. Through exercises, evaluations, tips and technologies, you can learn to write faster. Discover how to break through blocks, get ideas, develop plots, draft and polish in less time without losing quality.
Write Flash Fiction (Mar. 11-25) Face-to-face
Flash fiction is hot, with over 300 paying markets looking for well-formed stories of 1000 words or less. Learn how to write, market and sell these tiny tales.

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Endings That Suck - How to drive away readers

Hi, all
I'm blogging about endings over at the Savvy Authors site today. I provide a look at how things can go wrong. Understanding these potential problems is a good step toward creating wonderful endings.

I'll be teaching a course on Endings That Buzz at Savvy Feb 3-16.